This is book one of a phenomenal trilogy, of which I promise, you will be scrambling to read all three It will have your heart twisted up six ways to Sunday, and then some Paullina Simons is an extraordinary author She transports you back in time to 1941 during World War II in Leningrad, Russia, 1941 I felt like I was right in the midst of everything that was happening It was surreal.
Tatiana and Alexander will be seared into my heart forever The sacrifices they make for each other is nothing short of astounding.
It is simply an epic experienceOnce again, I m quite late to the party, as it was published in 2009, but it will most definitely be a re read for me One of my top 5 books and trilogies of ALL TIME, and that is saying something, considering all the books I have read over my many, many, many decades.
I went in blind of course and could not have been awed by what I was reading Honest to goodness it is just that amazing Thank goodness my library has the trilogy available, but this book is on sale right now on The Bronze Horseman is one of my all time favorites I decided to re read it, for probably the hundredth time, and it still moves me just as much as it did the first time The story of Alexander and Tatiana is so beautifully told and gripping that I can never put it down once I start To think, I nearly passed over this book because I don t usually read historical romances That would have been a tragedy Thank God, I finally gave it a shot after hearing so much praise for it I really would have missed out if I had.
I don t give many 5 star ratings, but I would have given this book 500 if I could have Nothing I could say would do this book justice, it is just that incredible If you haven t read it, do it now You won t be sorry This epic tale of love and loss is a must read for any romance reader LOVE this story The Golden Skies, The Translucent Twilight, The White Nights, All Hold The Promise Of Youth, Of Love, Of Eternal Renewal The War Has Not Yet Touched This City Of Fallen Grandeur, Or The Lives Of Two Sisters, Tatiana And Dasha Metanova, Who Share A Single Room In A Cramped Apartment With Their Brother And Parents Their World Is Turned Upside Down When Hitler S Armies Attack Russia And Begin Their Unstoppable Blitz To LeningradYet There Is Light In The Darkness Tatiana Meets Alexander, A Brave Young Officer In The Red Army Strong And Self Confident, Yet Guarding A Mysterious And Troubled Past, He Is Drawn To Tatiana And She To Him Starvation, Desperation, And Fear Soon Grip Their City During The Terrible Winter Of The Merciless German Siege Tatiana And Alexander S Impossible Love Threatens To Tear The Metanova Family Apart And Expose The Dangerous Secret Alexander So Carefully Protects A Secret As Devastating As The War Itself As The Lovers Are Swept Up In The Brutal Tides That Will Change The World And Their Lives Forever I m really quite confused.
This book came very highly recommended I picked it, along with a few others, from Goodreads top 100 romance novels It has been recommended to me many times over the years, from people on Goodreads and from those I know in real life And it has an average rating of 4.
While I didn t loathe the book and enjoyed some parts the truth is that than half of these 600 pages were excruciatingly boring.
Simons takes some steps towards goodness, but then it is ruined by the prolonged, tedious nature of everything that happens For example, Tatiana and Alexander s initial flirtations are exciting it s easy to get caught up in the angst of young love and all the issues that lie between them being together But the story moves at a snail pace, describing their frequent walks and bus rides in intricate detail Everything I enjoyed soon soured and became dull.
Similarly, the tale of how people lived in Soviet Russia and the fear that came with Hitler s invasion was a great setting for this wartime love story What a difficult time and place to try and deal with boyfriend problems And yet, the story is once again bogged down by pages and pages describing the same things over and over how many times do I need to hear about the food rationing I get it everybody s hungry Let s move on The bigger picture is fascinating, but the extent of the details and repetition is mind numbing.
Also, as much as I m a sucker for a touch of love angst now and then, I was never completely sold on the whole forbidden love aspect of this novel I don t really know how I feel about the way Tatiana s sister Dasha was portrayed If you ve yet to read this book, Tatiana meets a handsome young soldier and they have an instant connection Only it turns out that this soldier has been seeing and sleeping with her older sister So, of course, Tatiana does the only right thing and refuses to be with him.
I could practically hear the author s thought process running through my mind as I was reading.
Step 1 Think up a situation that would create a forbidden love scenario It has to be bad so readers will get all caught up in the angsting The solution hot soldier boy is already dating her sister Step 2 We all know that women who get it on with their sister s boyfriends have a very special level of hell reserved for them, so Dasha must be portrayed in a way that will make us forgive Tatiana for her relationship with Alexander The solution make Dasha a selfish, abusive, whiny little bitch I didn t like the way it was handled I felt like Dasha was only a bitch to justify poor, innocent Tatiana s actions And I also felt like it didn t make sense for Tatiana to sacrifice her relationship with Alexander when Dasha was evidently such an awful piece of work Tatiana exhibits behaviour of a classic Mary Sue self sacrificing, innocent, supposedly plain and yet desired by every male in the book.
Everything about this novel seems overwrought From the exaggerated innocence vs villainous qualities of the characters, to the constant rehashing of old details You know when you finish a book and think half of those pages would have sufficed This is one of those times.
Blog Facebook Twitter Instagram Tumblr One of the best books I ve ever read, so heart wrenching but that s the beauty of it Tatiana and Alexander s story was truly memorable and amazing.
Full thoughts appear on my blog bottom line is that this book normalizes and promotes unhealthy and abusive interactions between a husband and a wife Never once did Simons denounce any of Alexander s actions as abusive, violent, or wrong instead, Tatiana is constantly apologizing for upsetting his husband It s sold as a love story, but the main character is only given this love when she s behaving like a perfect doll for her husband, following his commands, serving him food, and bending over for him any time he feels the urge to pound her Alexander faced no consequences for his actions in this book This violence and this abuse is sold as angst and romance And I loathed every goddamn second of it.
Good bye, my moonsong and my breath, my white nights and golden days, my fresh water and my fire Good bye, and may you find a better life, find comfort again and your breathless smile, and when your beloved face lights up once at the Western sunrise, be sure what I felt for you was not in vain Good bye, and have faith, my TatianaReread 04 13 2017 God, I love this book so much It s far from perfect but this book and these characters are just so near and dear to my heart It s been almost a year since I read The Bronze Horseman the first time and to this day, I still haven t found a love story as great as Tatiana and Alexander s.
I don t know what it is but my heart just aches every time I flip through these pages It felt as if I was reading this book again for the first time because I cried, swooned, and bawled some just has much as I did the first time around I think The Bronze Horseman will always be my favorite love story of all time, and I ll never get tired of reading about the lives of Tatiana and Alexander 3 original Review I have no words to express my feelings towards this book All I know with utmost confidence is that I might have just read my FAVORITE book of all time I think I ve also taken binge reading to a whole new level because I literally just finished an 800 page book within a span of a day I kid you not This book devoured me and haunted me even in my sleep for 24 straight hours I gave up life and food because I couldn t put this book down Even now I m still reeling and withdrawaling from everything I just read.
Our two main characters Alexander and Tatiana are the epitome of tragedy Their whole story from beginning to end was just heart wrenching They are the perfect example of lovers who met and loved at the wrong time, especially when the beginning of their love story was also the beginning of the Second World War.
Since the very beginning and for most of the story, Alexander and Tatiana s relationship or lack thereof was put in a very complicated position You just can t help but root for them anyways no matter how bad things may likely turn out in the end The lengths that they went to just to bury their feelings for each other was absolutely dreadful The chemistry and the tension between Alexander and Tatiana was just so thick that it pained even me for them to be apart When they do finally get together, it feels like absolute euphoria just knowing you were waiting hundreds of pages for this moment to finally happen And I must say, those hundreds of pages were definitely worth the wait because I completely adore the both of them They weren t exactly sunshine and rainbows every step of the way, and their fighting got irritating because basic communication proved to be such a struggle for these two, but nonetheless I loved them anyways Their love was undying and sacrificed so much for even just a quick glance or the brush of a hand Even at the brink of death, even in the end, Alexander and Tatiana just lived and breathed love for one another.
As individuals, Alexander and Tatiana had their own flaws Tatiana was very naive in the beginning but war and loss sculpted her into a strong, kind young woman These qualities were also her weakness because it led people, especially her family, to often take advantage of her generosity and kindness She was the ultimate pushover and I really wanted to shake some sense into herself at times A lot of times She was also stubborn to no end and often put herself and Alexander in difficult situations But I admire Tatiana s endurance and perseverance for overcoming the war and the sacrifices she had to make for herself and for her family.
Alexander was a bit complicated to understand I could tell without a doubt that he loved Tatiana than life itself He spoke of love not with words but through his actions Sometimes I think he may have even loved her a little too much One of the things I worry about in regards to his character though was his temper He became very temperamental as the story progressed and I did feel as if his anger got the best of him The characters he lashed out to did become a bit testy but sometimes he got a bit too carried away with his rage Though I feel a bit guilty about saying this, I must admit that I won t be surprised if abuse becomes an issue with Alexander in the later books Pushes and shoves can easily turn into slaps and punches I m hoping it won t happen since I absolutely love Alexander aside from his many flaws, but it won t come as a shock if it does happen.
Aside from the romance, I really enjoyed reading World War 2 in the Soviet Union s perspective rather than America s or even Germany s I ve read a few historical fiction novels that were set during the Second World War but I ve never read one that was centered in the Soviet Union We all know that many countries lost a lot of lives in the war but just reading about what the people went through really hurts my heart I can t even imagine being starved to death like many of those civilians did I couldn t even eat a proper meal while reading this book because these characters were only given scraps for food I haven t read a book like The Bronze Horseman that s actually affected me this way emotionally.
This book is absolutely huge It s definitely the longest book I ve read and I ve successfully read it within a day Though the length of this book could be debatable, I really think it plays a huge role in the book itself We, as readers, are living through this war with the characters We are growing and suffering with each and every one of them I don t think this book would ve affected me as much if it was any shorter There were parts that felt repetitive and possibly could ve been omitted but I wouldn t change this book for the world It s not the greatest piece of literature out there in the world, nor is it the greatest love story every told but it comes pretty close to me.
I ve heard about The Bronze Horseman a few months ago but I never really gave it a second thought because I don t normally read historical fiction novels What a mistake that was I sincerely regret not picking this book up sooner because I can honestly say that The Bronze Horseman has topped every book I ve ever read so far in my life I always thought that The Night Circus, a fantasy novel, would always be my favorite book of all time I didn t doubt it because after several years and after hundreds of books, no book has ever replaced The Night Circus as my all time favorite Until today On top of that, fantasy has been my preferred genre of books to read This might have even been my first historical fiction book I ve read all year and we re already halfway done with 2016 I was never really planning to read this book or any historical fiction novel any time soon I just spontaneously decided to read a war romance and stumbled upon The Bronze Horseman even when I was already reading two other books But that dropping everything for this book was one of the greatest reading decisions I ve ever made in my life I can t even fathom how this book has impacted and affected me so greatly I m almost too afraid to read the next two books for fear that they won t live up to the the greatness of The Bronze Horseman But after that ending, after all that suffering, there has to be a happy ever after in store for these two untimely lovers I refuse to believe that this is the end for Alexander and Tatiana.
Oh what fresh hell I thought this book would never, ever end I never knew how important perfect white teeth could be, that there was such a thing as a slight case of TB, that this many mentions of blueberries could be squeezed into a single book, or that I could ever get bored with by sex But these things have all been achieved by Bronze Horseman She even manages to throw in some scurvy.
The description in this book is endless Buses, walks, dinners, ice cream, cabbage, love session, buses, walks, dinners, ice cream, cabbage, love session On and on it goes for hundreds of pages I m at a loss, are we supposed to be blown away by Ms Simmons ability to convey the monotony of everyday life Also, I m assuming this story was meant to be a love story but 1 I would dump anyone doing my sister while falling in love with me 2 I would never drop the man of my dreams for a hussy who beat me, even if I was related to her Nope, no way This book was horrid, the characters were laughable, and if I never see a blueberry again, it will be too soon Same goes for cabbage.
10 bright shining starsWow WOWWOWThis is themost intense and epic love story EVER told It s exquisitely written, achingly heart wrenching, deeply heart warming, and utterly beautiful, unforgettable and incomparable in every way Quite simply, there is no other series like this.
The author has a truly uncanny gift for really making you FEEL everything that her characters are going through I FELT Tania and Alexander fall in love, I FELT their longing, I FELT their desire, FELT their heartache, FELT their joy, FELT their hunger, FELT their pain, FELT their happiness, FELT their loss, FELT their desperation, but than anything FELT theirLOVELove that was all consuming, world shattering, achingly deep, and EPIC Honestly, I was an absolute wreck throughout my reading of it I literally stayed up reading till the sun came up and got up 4 hours later to finish it Throughout the entire book, I felt as though I was being constantly injected with little bouts of adrenaline It kept merivetedthe entire time This book ripped my heart out and put it back together over and over and over again I cried a few times throughout the book and then there was a part about 3 4 of the way though where I literally sobbed for about 12 15 straight pages And then I held out until the second last page and the waterworks started again You want SO BADLY for things to work out for them The story basically follows Tatiana, a 17 year old Russian girl from Lenningrad, who on the day that WW2 started in their area, meets Alexander, a 22 year old soldier in the Red Army with a secret past that could be very dangerous for him and anyone around him if it got out Tania s sister has recently also found a soldier who she is absolutely smitten with and, of course, Tania then finds out that Alexander is indeed that soldier that Dasha has fallen for Tatiana s is the ultimate selfless giver she puts everyone else before her no matter the personal costs and even though she and Alexander are clearly crazy for each other, she cannot bear the thought of breaking her sister s heart and begs him to pretend to stay with her sister This leads to a lot of tension, obviously, and many stolen glances, and gestures, looks, fleeting touches, private names for each other and secret meetings Over the months they fall deeper and deeper in secret love But eventually the war comes right to Lenningrad and they are forced to all fight for survival When Tatiana and Alexander eventually get married, they have a beautiful month long hot hot hot 70 page honeymoon this IS a romance story after all despite the tragic setting I won t say but the ending leaves you hanging and desperate for the next book This is book 1 of a trilogy I have it on good authority that the last one ends with a HEA but its a long and bumpy road until then It s not your classic romance where everything just works out , it s a heart wrenching journey of finding love and having the faith to hold on to it no matter what Alexander sigh how to describe him He is one ofthosemale character that just sears themself into your mind The way he LOVES Tania and the way she LOVES him is just so POWERFUL and BEAUTIFUL I really can t do it justice with my own words They sacrifice SO much, EVERYTHING for each other I loved how Tatiana grew from a quiet young girl to a very strong woman throughout the book.
I just want to pluck the two of them out of this story, put them on a desert island with everything they could every want to live out their lives in perfect happiness They literally have all possible odds stacked against them and yet still the push through This is truly a story about survival About how love can give you the will and the courage to survive anything The book is long My print copy was 810 pages but I promise you, it does not feel long at all I read every single word often as slowly as I could I didn t skim a single syllable The author s writing style is beautiful and flows very smoothly The story never dragged for me If you want an EPIC love story with wonderful characters and beautiful writing, this is the book for you I get asked this A LOT How historical are these books so I m going to answer that here NOT AT ALL Ok, well maybe a tiny bit considering it takes place during WW2, but the point is that it doesn t FEEL like a historical book at all I personally am not a fan of historical romances mainly because I don t like the language In this book, the characters speak in MODERN language They sound pretty much like you or I would Also, the book does NOT go into any lengthy detail on historical events This is first and formost a LOVE STORY The focus is on the characters, NOT the events The only events that are highlighted are the ones that DIRECTLY affect the main couple The rest of the war, etc is pretty much glossed right over You do learn some facts because obviously they live through the war, but its the background The story follows ALEXANDER and TATIANA, their life and their love Trust me, you will NOT regret reading it D10 stars and a place high on my favorites shelf.
Bottom line The Bronze Horseman IS THE BEST, MOST INTENSE, MOST INCREDIBLY BEAUTIFUL AND HEART WRENCHING YET HEART WARMING LOVE STORY EVER TOLD A MUST read Trust me You ll never forget this storyAsk yourself these three questions, Tatiana Metanova, and you will know who you are Ask what do you believe in What do you hope for But most important ask what do you love I know who I am, she thought, taking his hand I am Tatiana And I believe in, and hope for, and love Alexander for lifeMY CASTING see aboveTo sum it up For of my reviews, book news and updates Main blog Aestas Book Blog Facebook Blog Page Twitter
85 haha Those problems were pure maiden trope got slightly old and happiness was so closely related only to sex which got a little repetitive I might probably will be doing a mini review on this 2017 update lowering the rating because the maiden trope mentioned earlier is problematic than my naive self picked up on 3 years ago It s pretty dang creep sketch Kept it at 2 stars because the Russian war setting is still done well.